The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink Aboutpitkin.boa.95.04.. ~. , DATE I ~ 'V` REPRESENTATIVE MAILING ADDRESS OWNER 1 )!1C ~( ~b eo MAILING, ADDRESS _/ a LOCATION OF PROPERTY c M N S cs^0 o nf~v e Any pertinent data must accompany this application, and will be made part of this Case. The. Board may return this application ;f it does not contain all the owner's Signature (To be completed by the Zoning Department) ~~ JJ L .QOA t/, Provisions of the zoning resolution requiring the Zoning Official to forward this application to the Board of Adjustment, and reasons _ for not granting a building permit: F~10 Zone District Requesting: bt~~~~ ~- `~y~., ~'?~ Lot Size 'zN"~~^~'''~j ~~' ' Front Yard Setback Variance, where ~i~Cz ' is required. ' Rear Yard Setback Variance, where ' is required. ' Side Yard Setback Variance, where ' is required. ' _, Side Yard Setback Variance, where ' is required. ~' Height Variance, where ~~ is required. Square Feet where a maximum of sq. ft. is allowed. Other: ~~p'a ~ ~ ~~;~ V-~%! ~~,,.~.CJL ,ern n n4~n~ ::~ . „ ~ n"fi'~ , , „t- .,, „ -i,~~ 30` r -? .., Zoning Officia ~ _Q~`~~,,a ~ , Application filed 3 l3 qS ParcID No. Z`1 I I - (zl -0 (_Dd(D Date of Meeting ~ '- q~ ', f Notices Mailed 23 Secretary _ U~-c. ~ V~/ 2 U _~~- Refer Resolution to ild ~g Department ~ _i yes ~ ~ ,_, No ~~ ~~~ CASE # / Jr' ~ `J PHONE `-,`LZ 9 _ PHONE ~ ~ 52f ")~~,1~ g ~ ~c /Z (6J~It~ ~ _ , _,.. _~ ,_. ~ ~ ~ _ < ,u~. ~. z ~d . NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING TO AD ACEl~T"`PROPERTY OWNERS BEFORE THE PITKIN COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT VARIANCE DESCR B D BELOW FFECTED BY THE REQUESTED ZONING ~ OR USE Pursuant to Pitkin County Resolution of June 5, 1955, as amended, a Public Hearing will be held in City Council Chambers, City Hall, First Floor, Aspen, Colorado (or at such other place as the meeting may then be adjourned) to consider an application filed with the said Board of Adjustment requesting authority for variance from the provisions of the County Zoning Resolution. All persons affected by the proposed variance are invited to appear and state their views, protests or objections. If you cannot appear personally at such meeting, then you are urged to state your views by letter, particularly if you have objection to such variance, as the Board of Adjustment will give serious consideration to the opinions of surrounding property owners and others affected in deciding whether to grant or deny the request for variance. AS FOLLOWS:LARS OF THE HEARING AND OF THE REQUESTED VARIANCE ARE Date and time of meeting: Owner: Owner's Address: Property Location or Description: June 6, 1995 at 5:15 p.m. Commissioners Meeting Room Courthouse Plaza John Goodwyne c/o JN Johnson Sales & Service 1401-G West River Road North Minneapolis, MN 55411 6770 Castle Creek Road Lot 1, Block 1, Filing 1, Lime Village Requesting approval fora 5' front yard setback variance for abedroom/garage addition; a 23' front yard setback variance for a new entry; and a 19.5' front yard setback variance and a west side yard setback variance for an addition to be added beneath the existing house; where a 30' front yard setback and a 20' side yard setback are required fora 92,779 square foot lot in the AFR-10 zone district; and a height variance to allow a 30' retaining structure within the setbacks. VARIANCES GREATER OR LESS THAN REQUESTED COULD BE GRANTED. Duration of Variance: Temporary Permanent X THE PITKIN COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT r ti Suzanne L. Wo f ; eLS cretary 130 S. alena Street, Aspen, CO 81611 (970)920-5093 ,. a .~<,...rs~ ~.~M, kwS.~%w M~ ~~- io ~ i 'a ~~ l ,~ D E2 N _~ G N t~' ~°I!.!? - 12.x- Z.,3q ~ . r i 1 ~ U T (,1 iZ ~ CT 4 ¢. AGr~ , . Rte ~~'~ ~ fI !- - ~ ~TLK ~ ~ ? ~ N -p ;per: flD ~, ~ .~ LE ~L o0%2,5 __.__ Qjn r~ m ,--~IJ 6~ ~~-O`~ ~ 0012.. d d f J4 -~ "~. T CC71' ~'C A 1~ 1 ~ G7" L. ~ nl E IL]L ~ ~ T ~ _ „ ,, ,, + V ~ + ~. ~Oo:T~ ~1 uFiQ. ~OL~ ~Sp~-~-t~ ~ ~ 5.c""Ca.. ~ v e. n, ~ ~R- i 1 ~ ~~ ,~ _~ , STo N G ~4~aa--rr1 ~ CUT ~~.oofT~ ~'oh. W M d 2 S~ l._~ y Fem. ~ O GLf.~Qpn~G~ L ! D ~~c•~C. F.~~ ~~~ .J~o~~rs P»at~ otii ~ ` ec. a~ . ~N a ~ Z~.~;~~ I . a.^Z~, ov~TZ~,C7 cG1L ~~11a ~~vE~ ~~r_rt~V~T t otit5 GA,t.1E~ ~~-ro Nc Ft,,.e2 ~ , To - H o ~'W 6' ~N :d- ~7r z`~ ~~h Variance Request -Page 2 The final variance request is for permission to have a retaining wall system that is higher than 30 inches tall in the front yard setback. In order to adequately access this residence with vehicles, the cut required by a turn around needs to be retained. A tall wall is much more environmentally sound than a series of 30 inch retaining walls would be in this case because of the steep slopes envolved. Thirty inch high retaining walls would require approximately an additional seventy feet of destruction of the natural grade and its vegetation which would then be related with man made terraces. Finally this retaining wall system will not 'interfere with anyones ability to see approaching traffic along the main access street or driveway. Thank you for' your patience and consideration in this matter as well as your time and civic responsibility in serving on this Board of Adjustment. ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNERS- LOT 1 LIME VILLAGE Alice Davis & Glen Horn P 0 Box 2015 Aspen, CO 81612 Castle Creek Investors Inc. µ c/o John Mi-ler P 0 Box 267 Cambridge City, IN 47327 Heinz & Elaine Pagels Aspen Center for Physics 600 West Gillespie St. Aspen, CO 81611 James Nelson Albert P 0 Box 637 Aspen, CO 81612 Randal S. Gold P 0 Box 9813 Aspen, CO 81612 Judy Kendall Hyde 55 Cherry Road Memphis, TN 381 17 Molly Hunt Heizer P 0 Box 10132 Aspen, CO 81612 U S Forest Service- White River Nat'I Forest 806 West Hallum Aspen, CO 8161 1 FX (-F i ~ i I `~~ r I 383751 _ B-788 P-3E,7 07/27/95 04 e 42P FG :, OF . ~'~efnwc~ Laa1e rlwpER-'~`i L.HC ' ~~~- ~' ;- ,~ .. ' - ~, ~.-' o BALD l ' - e ~ ~t i ~: tv N7tM- - ~~ ~ ~~ - ~ raa.~ .NI ~1sPaNS , v„~~ ,,,,1- ~ ~~ '" "-' - ,. ~ ,~ . ~ ~ SExV acc Baez ~ ~ i I, I' I I _ F~KI~TINGt ~#w.D W A~' ~i,. a ~~ A936 ~utrE-/+f36 ~. 215 ~! f ~ C WN P ~.9i~+~ ~ ~ ~ ~' '~' j li ~ _~ ~ _- E~YST IN4 ~~ AIL ~ I ~ !~', ". . f I ~/;. .s, p~¢vai 4a,'e.tq WeaT^3m~ ~ ~ i~"~ - a- Pw`w~t~ts 1 TiMw~ lnov~Nn/ \ j j r / 'Tc~4 n1Pi~'IJ ~l~T. V1iYt~.~ . i ~ ~ ~. - \\, r - - ~ ~. > P GRT'{ ~-, Aye IT"E ! i 1~ ~ o ,. s - ~-R o~7~ w Y -J E L~SIT~K.A1G"E F'Al IILLU AS:~U(:~IA I L-5 ENGINEERS. INC. 77 5 GRAND AVENUE P O BU% 75 t'~ GLENWUUD SPRINGS. CUL~ORADO G7 GC2 (303) 945-9695 FA% (3031 945-452'1 _..' Z7o - ~o - 21~ - Zoe - ~ ,~., ~ Une o ~ g ro,@ ~ / ~~~•,~ ~M P~~ ,~ l r.:::_ -- ~:- - ~. _~ i ~ ~ y _ -- ~ --__ ,- _i.~~'~V GIB ~IJ` < I _~ ~~RDJED7 l~ , ~i rrN ~~r ~~n~w ~^ ~~..DATE Imo. ".' OY SHEET DR # U ~ ~ ~- Q ~ C~ PJ/}'%h677 ,710N - l~ ~..___.._ ~- ---___ ~ ~ iH l~ h r_? r ~~ J. ~Ir ~ j I ~~' LI I~l ~~~ S ~- ~ ~,~ ~~- Sic, J~J>~~~'~~ GftFV7~L~'il~- ~~p'~'j(~J~IJG Wi91iL -COr~+,. kE•~sr~t~~ sJr~,~, 2~0- rE~, c~-Nn~ ~~u~ ~,ufi~t- t 7~.~ ~5~~~1 ~ r o~~ Cs~! k_.. ~..-~~ i i IvdQ..T ~oj.~UNclf~c.lw. EI ~~~` 5~~~ ~C.-tit' ~~rJ ~ , ~ rn'~~ c..~ -I-o ~~Y1~wp.` ~'L M~~c ~- ~a~i S}~.~~jt ;~`' ~"~ ~ r'~ (z ~~!'~~}}IG ~AS~ • a ~, ; ~, 13 MarcheT995 Joanna S. Schaffner, County Zoning Officer . ., ,. Aspen/Pitkin Planning Depar'tmei~ ` 130 South Galena Street ~° Aspen, CO. 816 2 , ` Deaf" Ms. ,Schaffner:, . ^ . w . - -~.. ,. . _.. . ,._ ~ ~ _ . °. ' 'This letter is to notify you of my desire to have. Gordon Denton represent '' `'me before the Pitkin C~urity°Board of Adjustment in a'hearing to request a varatl~2 from the setti~`~k"wequirements""bf lfitkin County ~~ ~R "" ~`" F.:,,. ~ .:.~ . -~..~ ,,,~. .h ~: ~.r rxgq?F ~ ,~~ Respectfully Submitted, ~ ,~~..~~~~ ~ ~ ~.~ /~ John G/oodwyne ~~Y~ " c/o J.N. Johnson Sates & SeYirid~"~' ~~~_~..~, 1401-G West River Road ` Minneapolis, MN. 55411 ,., , ~ ~ r`a.~~~ =per=, ~ ' ~ ~t >xY« n~f.`,' M~. ,~.: y , :.. ,,.. .: "°..a:.'s~'nea~'a3.~5+"~'""Scf::3~?6,. „,... .3~?:'?,":~..~?`„?~~.'6~:.",',;^X `i'r~,..:~tE..t.~ i.f ~.•ttn:."''... -. s~ im ~~ ~: - - . ... ~~ ~( & roSb ?!*~-i54,SSKTFk 1 &.'f'E^~, .~. 7+w` i) "~+a^'t141s z4 `3#~"4+~} ~kwi 1'"SS'g d !?%~rfi ~,F','~X~'t't3' d~ a+,~e} sSd ~ ;+nz -n ~ ~°~ . Zvi +"`nnsr 4A [5~+ ~_y~;.~C a ~~"x% ~ ~ ~~a . -+ .1j C'~': 'jam',. b^.k'~,*t~+i Zi.,$"1' ~ *~.t` ;t~+ iA~f. y m. wh'~^~`'~ ' ., a ~.s~-.~;a v^ '" 4-°°tA , t"1ziS, ~'s£~.C`$~' `~,#u. :'Sl4~A ~~iSY,sF~$'; " SPd~. ~i".~e:7Yf~',xu wy- ks' i~~,`~,+~+ ,r ,: .. . ww';p}Nwwxa~aY *tiC ~ ;~ !~Y~i"?`,"+as"~°~i>°~XY~'iGY~Z',"r~,u 4~'~u6~sk~.~k - ~ ,. ;~ w. r y _.., , .~:... ?3. r';..: +z?". F";~~, =i7i'i~'2.* ~*8' l`~a" ~i}`,~.' ~nthA~.°u~""°yya~"j.°~s. C"~a'~~ "k~."Ea k`M"[::~'&R f^'"f" ~ry*7~ 8~3. ... s +~ ~:rt' ~, ' "~'?„G?.' ' ~. . `^~~i Y '"S'~'' c~t8~ ~§aks~s3#°s°fr T".e'9o."°+~'. Y ~ S ,. f i ~,~.`° United States Forest Department of Service Agriculture White River ~ Aspen Ranger District National 806 West Hallam Sf. Forest Aspen, CO 8161 Y 303-925-34d5 " " TDD 363-920.3~hA Reply To: 2736 Date: March 30, 1995 Pitkin County Board of Adjustments 130 South Galena Street Aspen, CO 81611 Ladies and Gentlemeh: APR 0 4 1995 DEVELC~r'~.4ENT ViilagelSubdNSion (Cooi)rerates to ftfe72quest by'`Mr. John ~"o`o"tiwyrie"fo~-'setback 4a~ianoes at of ime ""~"-- 9 q that Fnvate andiactiva es be strict) kef~on theair ate land. It would be arudenlt for Mnts It os our expectation p y p p p Goodwyne'to Have his lot surveyed and his boundary lines marked in a visible and durable manner. Aspen Ranger District will soon initiate formal National Ehvironmental Policy Act (NEPA) analysis on a request that Mr. Goodwyne has presented to the Forest Service. Mr. Gobdwyne desires a road authorization for the driveway which serves the residence on Lot 1. Construction of a replacement driveway, that would be totally on private land, would require very high cut banks and would result in major degradation of visual resources. Therefore, I believe that Mr: Goodwyhe probably will be granted a road easement that will authorize construction and use of a driveway, more or less along the existing route across National Forest land. Please call Allan Grimshaw at this office (925-3445) 'rf there are any questioris regarding this information, SinrarcM1i cc: Mr. John Goodwyne; Mr. Gordori Denton; Ms. Ellen Sassano. Caring for the Land and Serving the People ~;;~? Aspen/Pitkn Cammunty Dt'~•elopment I9epartrvent 130 South Galena Street Aspen, Calorada 81611. (303)920-5090 City Land Use Application Fees: 00113-63850-041 Deposit - -63855-042 Flat Fee - -63860-043 HPC -- - -63875-046 Zo:ring & Sign Pernrit __ __ - NIlt011 Use Tae County Land.Use Application Fees: 0113-63800-033 Deposit __ -63805-034 Flat Fee ~_______ -b3820-037 Zoning -63825-038 Board of Adjustment __ ~_. Referral Fees: 00113-63810-035 Coun[yEngineex 00115-63340-163 City lrngineer 00123-63340-190 Housing 00125-63340-205 Envromental Health Sales: 00113-63830-039 County Code -69000-145 Copy Fees Address: Other -Total ~ DC7 . OCR /~-I~YOiJ Date3~i3~~7~ Check: ~3JY' Phone: ~/o~ ~ - =' =' ~ No. of Copies .. . ~~ „~ w ~. ~~ • . ~,~ R..~ ~.. ..w3., ,,:7 , . .~,~ County of Pitkin } AFFIDAVIT OF NOTICE BY } ss. POSTING OF A VARIANCE HEARING Btate of Colorado } BEFORE THE pITRIN COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT The undersigned, follows: I, being or representing an Applicant before the Pitkin County Board of Adjustment, personally certify that the attached photograph fairly and accurately represents the sign posted as Notice of the variance hearing on this matter in a conspicuous place on the subject property (as it could be seen from the nearest public way) and that the said sign was post d and visible continuously from the ~ ~ day of 1 ~, to the ~_ day of 19 (Must be posted for at least nine (9) full days befc~r~,L~he~hea iriq da~~~}-. -~ 1 .worn to be re me _, r AND OFFICIAL SEAL. ~- ~pires • ~"r' ' ~ ! " r' ~~~ ~~ c ~ ~-~ . s S igr,~~ture ~ .~, ,„ being first duly sworn, deposes and says as i ~`' ~.. J, • ~' r , ~, ~'` - CONTOUR INrER~AL 2' ~,-:` / . ~/ I TOF ~ ~9/: ;.~ .I „2 .....~.. SG/L /JA/L W.4 L HEIGHT (7YP.) ~/ p~ "' "~ ~ ~ ' / ,_ T'JP OF WALL £LEV. ~~ ~:~ Y ~~ ,.. .y - _ .---_ _ _ I _ o, M.. ,~ .. - h ~ Yom...--;~._. ..- + . . .. err'/~ "".. "... ~ ~ r ~,~ . .~ I. S FSgcK To ~V c R-'6•f f4nlC~- ~~-' " ~` I l ~ `/ x ~ 1 % ' ~. • ~ ~ PROPERTY L/NE ~ ' ~ . _. ~ _.__ ., .% ~ /'~ ~ `/. j ~, ,; f ~ , ~.. ~ , , . .,:~~_, ~e ,A. ....r.tfo 2 x ~ ..p.u.~, ^~~ s ~ .. ._.a_~_Cw i _Q I X r M ~a _ , .. _. lay-1130N Jo~-E3'~ !0~-'4~~~."j~_p~2~~ '~4-t-'•4 c'LE Mti3"f~"~.. V1TE' -~ ~ujL/AE ACG~3S~ ~ U PPE.Cz LLVE~ ~ .n4o UAT ~a~~ Spa ~.e. /4„ ~ 1 ~ o „ i O h ~~ ___ - ,_ vV.l~. W.u. nr. ~ ,~ _a ~ 1~ - =\ ~ ~ ~ O ~ 'd' ~ ~ ~ 'ap,Y t1 N ,~ "i i ' ~ le x IZ E N eve ~ - `' t 1 G.~U ~ Atit's TO `~ ~ Q i ~ .SwPpo~ Z eQ..~ ~ ~ h cs. F P. w ~ ~ G'aeaafl~l ~ 11 j~±YJoUE~ ~ __..._ i _ - - - - - - \°j ~ i ~,~ ' iv _ ( __ ._ .__ p- -~ ~j-r-a~ a.s yr -t-z~ Cn2r (Z M N O v C W Z5 GW Z S -~ _i .,_ ,. ____ 3 L'Ow.en, ~~ LA L.6- i 0 -o ~~~~.1._ ~~~oYA'Tta X15 /~ ~ ~-----1 0 ~I ~J L,.7 ICT 00'p W Y N E. --- ~. I i ` :.. . .zx', R.mrSr_ 4 ..:.. ., was, :' Va9 ~ 1 ~. 4n~Ae x"':. y. ~ / ~ ~; ~'-~o'~~, 2'-a'~'~ s'-3'12" ~~'`-Za I UTU~Z~ CTA¢AGr~ I. I ^ ~1 Eras R~2 -~ REr/ RA~Ci i i ~ .~ I L - ~ i ~ / 0 / 4 a - ~OVJ I DER i ~ W~ A ~ ~ ~ ~u ~- , _; ~_ .._~ N -I 4. : G ~ ~ ~" i i ~Q m 0 ~~ 0002 .ro !J E11 ~,~- ~ - _ r S1i? ~ A ~ ~ ~ jp , u _ a0. ~; ~ ~L-~A~- T~'oo ~`~ _-----. ~ G a iz ner" L., nt E , ~ ~ 4--~- ~__._____ I N ' ~ r. Wo ~ ~~~R iVF..Q. (ZOG)rCSP~~-r~ ae2. ' i 3~- ~ 0~1 ' ToMaT~ ~ ~ ~ --- -~ ~-+ a~N N STO N G ~,AR-TN ~ ~ _ 1 ~~ w CUT K~ooR- Fof~- .d. r , ~ .._ A G4u~i~S TO LOy~IC~i~Z.. 1J14~ ~S'i'I c ^I 'ct' ~ WM4aS~ l..cV~- Q ~I.f.A¢pnIGS (,-ID Pj L.ac1G. - _ lR F.ra~ fh.fi,~E ~o~51"s ~~~4f~ DN {~ ~IJ A t:._ ez.. o.e~ . .~} z -3`~ - %~ _~ v ' I' ~'J p .., ;r . ~ ~ z ~ s '~~,P.1~ ~EVEt.._. R~loVAT 1 c~rt5 ~. f~y ~ ~OO ~ 1 l ~~` ~. ~c/ ~ ,, e~ ~; ~~.,~ ,1, „~ ~$ ~ - r ' r ~ ' (~ a, %~ ~ ~ ~J. U ~~ r l v ~' ''7 Z n -) '~; r ~, ~ ~ , I ~_ + ajm ~- r , S'~ _, '' ~ d ~, ~, ~~ --r a v ~ .~- ~ ~%i v ''~ i -- - a ~, 0 r i~ ~ Z ,. 0 ~ ~ V1 ~/ ~~ /~ a ~' - .. .~ ~. ,w.. , . ,~ ...a ~. ... m ~r~ gpa~r, ~ 5 aDe ~.ll,~e /a - 2 - a is 1 i i~ -,. ,~ t."~ #~ ~~ .isrlnla St+il3cr~~Roor-.,. rig[ 1X3" :'- 1.1A..a~E~s ~J1°.R,,. Z'~ IZ~c.m~"bARA {~ pu2i,aN5 .. ,. __ r.. YBaN Y., {Z" GTLu LP,M 6L~"A6.~'S ~ ;. ....,.. t <. .. c 1 ~ST and G ~a~.T ~ Au..S ARE s~X lt+ `; ". ~ut,l~/ .TNSu t_4'Tt'D w lo" BAT'K,,,, ': ~aa sAta7z1~~4 ~ ~xIL P,oA2p4 .;.. _. ~ I St4 3carr+,y - ~u-r~2am~,~w~1~V vp21 es _ . ., . . FIIL~'La+o7i~µLt oVER...sf2,".PLy ~:"'. 'S u 3 F ~2i~o~` CS F(:ncrt+._ .1o~5is .@ 1(o"uC ' NC,0.rc.h E~ys-rirlcr Gflu~Y>~, ,;_,.., __~_ ._ ~~ G'Ob1C, Si-A1~ T'H~cKe>•Ict7 -40'6" ~.1'2~A t'i'. " wC1t.t.. @ KJ7r4 tR " Ktis'~'t*tC,r ~r~~a CI'STJN4r F~"T''1nlG "`~ E G'T" I A tl. Q EST W.Ac~„ C AI.E " ~ _ O '. O a Tj \,~1,t -~ ~ t ,ww: .. ~t ~ ~~~ ~. , ,ti.= ~,. T :.~~_ ~, 6 U. ~0 ~- 0 ~ ~, ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ P ` m L-- - x I ~ ~ ~, I a ~\ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ i ~ i ~ I - -1-- - -- ----- n ~ ~ ~ rr=--~ ~t ~ 1-~,- a ~d i ~ ~~ ~ $ r ~ ~ ~` r~ ~~ _ gt <a ,~ _ .. '+~ ^'r ,.,~ is ~ .' , , ` ,.. . ~. ~ p ._ _.~ . _a .. ',. ~' ~ . ~ i i ~ I~ ~. ~ i .. ~ ~ , ,. I e, it F ~ ... ° , ~, i ~ i ;, . . G ~ . .a, .. r ` ~ c !,,. .i~ a~1 . .. .u. •. ~. Ff ,. ~ ~ .. .. ^i. G i. ' ~f. I ~ " I ~~ •.. x „~~ ~~,~ v v. ~ "i... ~ ~i.. ~ ~.... ... ~ 1' i ~ 1 .::. A a.. ... 1:. 1 I ~~ . ii ~ ~ a n F ' .. i 1~ y i ~ .. IC . Y ~ ~ i _~~ h i Iry ~ ~~ 1 . Y' ~ ~ q ~ ~ . . qau y ~~ ~ a ? ~ .Vm' ~ ~ ~ii ~i i =~ ~~ ~~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ I '. 1. llt n._ ~ ` .._. .. r .' , n I~~ ~i ~ I i I I~ ~ ~1 j ~ d ~ ~ ~ I ~ l l I i ~ ~ I ' r ~ I I ~ t i. ~ 3a. 1. ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ,,. ~r . i ~ ..,.._..~...........~.~.~.,.F^e I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t / O 8-0°+ ~ ~i ~ ~ ~1 ~~ .. "Q .Q d q ~ , ~ ~ o _ G ~ S~1 r X u z (? A __ __ ~~-. a _ `-- J~ ~ _ ~ ,~ C \~' ~ 1 t ;~ e •. +w ~a _~ r~ d -c ~z r t+ d ryH .~ 11111 . ~' _J Off" ,~ ~~ t~ i~ ,, ~, ~, 1~ ~~ ,~ .~ ,~ ~. ,r ~C~er ~, 4F _~__~-_...~.--.,-r-c.~.~ ~, ,~ ~- 1 N f~ -~ 1 r o ~, ~ m rl m In ~ s rl ~- a ~` a° r; 3 1! )r ' ~ ~ ~~ 1 ,, ,, ., ~N~~~ ;1 <"`~ Y pf . h ,~ ~~ .' ., 1~ ti ri ~~ ~1 i~ ~~ .~ r. ''I 1~ 1 ~_., .~. u ._~... _ ~. _ .,. ~ ~. :;83751 B-788 P-365 ' /S7/35 4:42X' FAO 1 OF REC DOC Ni SILVIA DAVIS FITKIN COUN'T`Y CLEF7F~."& WR~C~(f~5'~"I~~"'~~`"u'~~"I~ RESOLUTION OF THE PITRIN COIINTY, COLORADO BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT GRANTING BETBACR RELIEF FOR JOHN GOODWYNE RESOLIITION NO. 95-04 WHEREAS John Good caner of 6770 Castle Creek Road, is q n a royal for a fo re uesto m/pgarage addition r a 5''front yard setback variance for the beds a 23' front yard setback variance for the entry; and a 19.5' front yard setback variance and a west side yard setback variance for an addition to be added beneath the existing house; and a 27.5' height variance for a retaining structure within the setback; and WHEREAS, a 30' front yard setback and a 20' side yard setback are re fired for a 92 779 s qu , quare foot l:ot in the AFR-10 zone district; and WHEREEAS,. 30" is allowed for a retaining wall in the setback; and WHEREAS, the subject.. property is described as Lot 1, Block 1, Filing 1, Lime Village, Pitkin County, Colorado; and, WHEREAS, the Board of Adjustment is vested with the power to'grant or deny such variances by virtue of Title TI, Section 16-1.3, Pitkin County Code (Land Use Code) and Colorado Revised Statutes, 1973,, 30-28-118(2) (C); and; makesAthebfollowinghfindingsce presented, the Board of Adjustment 1. Proper notice procedures, including the notification of all adjoining property owners, has been shown by the applicant. 2. The required hardship or practical difficulty has been established. 3. Granting such relief will not cause substantial detriment to the public welfare and will not substantially impair the intent and purpose of the Zoning Resolutions and the zoning maps. NOW THEREFORE BE IT following variances b REgSOLVEf) by the Board of Adjustment, that the e ranted: 1. 5 foot front yard setback variance for the bedroom/garage addition;' 2. 23 foot front yard setback variance for the entry; 3. 19.5 foot, .front yard setback variance and a 2 foot west side BEFORE THE PITKIN COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT TO ALL PROPERTY OWNERS AFFECTED BY THE REQUESTED ZONING OR 'USE VARIANCE DESCRIBED BELOW: Pursuant to Pitkin County Resolution of June 5, 1955, as amended, a Public Hearing will be held in City Council Chambers, City Hall, First Floor, Aspen, Colorado (or at such other place as the meeting may then be adjournedj'to consider an application filed with the said Board of Adjustment requesting authority for variance from the provisions of the County Zoning Resolution. All persons affected by the proposed variance are invited to appear and state their views, protests or objections. If you cannot appear personally at such meeting, then you are urged to state your views by letter, particularly if you have objection to such variance, as the Board of Adjustment will give serious consideration to the opinions of surrounding property owners and others affected in deciding whether to grant or deny the request for variance. THE PARTICULARS OF THE HEARING AND OF THE REQUESTED'CrA171ANCE ARE AS FOLLOWS: Date and time of meeting: owner: owner's Address: Praperty Location or Description: April 4, 1995 at 5:15 p.m. Council Chambers, City Hall. John Goodwyne c/o JN Johnson Sales & Service 1401-G West River Road North Mihneapolis, MN 55411 6770 Castle Creek Road Lot 1, Block 1, Filing 1, Lime Village bedroominarape add tion and 5a 23r~f ont yardtsetbackrvance for a /g g ariance for a new entry, where 30' is required for a 92,779 square foot lot in the AFR-10 zone districtj" and a height variance to allow a 30' retaining structure within the setbacks. Approval of this variance request would allow the proposed' bedroomJgarage addition to~be located 25' from the front property line and the entry to be located 7' from the front property line. VARIANCES GREATER OR LESS THAN REQUESTED COULIy SE GRAN'~ED. Duration of Variance: Temporary Permanent X THE PITKIN COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT Suzanne L. Wolff, Secretary NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING 1 TO ALL PROPERTY OWNERS Pursuant to Pitkin County Zoning Resolution of June, S, 1955, as amended, a Public Heazing will be held in the District Courtroom, Pitkin County Court House, Aspen, Colorado, (or at such other place as the meeting may then be adjourned) to consider an application filed with the said Board of Adjustment requesting authority for vaziance from the provisions of the County zoning Resolution. All persons affected by the proposed variance aze invited to appear and state their views, protests, or objections. If you cannot appear personally at such meeting, then you are urged to state your views by letter, particulazly if you have objection to such vaziance, as the Board of Adjustment will give serious consideration to the opinions of surroundtng property owners and others affected in VARIANCE GREATER THAN OR LESS THAN deciding whether to grant or deny the request for variance. A "TT3AT REQUESTED COULD BE GRAioITED. DATE AND TIME OF MEETING: Tuesday, June 6, 1995; 5:15 P.M. Commissioners' Meeting Room, Courthouse Plaza Goodwyne, John: requesting approval fora 5' front yazd setback variance for the bedroom/gazage addition; a 23' front yazd setback variance for the entry; and a 19.5' front yazd setback variance and a west side yard setback vaziance for an addition to he added beneath the existing house; where a 30' front yazd setback and a 20' side yazd setback aze required fora 92,779 square foot lot in the AFR-10 zone districts a 27.5' height vaziance, where 30" is allowed, for a retaining structure within the setback; a 5' height variance, where 20' is required for an accessory structure. Property Location: 6770 Castle Creek Road; Lot 1, Block 1, Filing 1, Lime Village. Urschel Trust: requesting approval fora 12' front yard setback variance, where 30' is required for an approximately 1 acre lot in the AFR-10 zone district; and a major road setback vaziance, where 100' is required; for a second floor addition to a detached gazage. Property Location: 1889 Maroon Creek Road; a tract of land in the NE'/4SEt/< of Section 15, Township 10 South, Range 85 West of the 6th P.M. Epstein/Gordy: requesting approval fora 5.5' front yazd setback vaziance for an addition, an 11' front yazd setback to upgrade the existing overhang area above the garage doore, and a 17.5' front yazd setback vaziance for a covered entry, where 30' is iequired fora 17,413 squaze foot lot in the R-15A zone district. Property Location: 0462 Mountain Laurel Drive; Lot 56, Block 2, Filing 2, Mountain Valley Subdivision. Pomegranate East Apartments: requesting approval for the following improvements to be located within the required 200' arterial highway setback, as measured from the Highway 82 right-of-way: gazages to be located within 150' of the right-of-way, trash enclosures to be located within 100' of the right-of-way, and berms to be located within 50' of the right-of--way. The berms will also encroach into the required 20' east side yazd setback. The applicants are also requesting to locate a sign along the highway within the required 100' setback and pazking within 50' of the highway righy right-of-way, where 100' is required. Property Location: 39060 Highway 82; a part of Lot 4 in Section 11, Township 10 South, Range $5 West of the 6th P.M. Submitted to the Aspen Times on May 23, 1995. To Be Published in the Aspen Times on May 27, 1995. Pitkin County Account ,,, o e ~fis m e spen tmes on azc Pitkin rremty drrn....r NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE PITKIN COUNTY BOARD OF ADIUSTMENT TO ALL PROPERTY OWNERS AFFECTED BY TEiE REOC7`E"STEb"'ZC)NINCr VARIANCE Distrito Courtroom, P~itkin ~ounryZCourtgHouseut%penJCoi'S, 1955, as amended, a Public Heazing will be held in the orado, (or at such other place as tha meeting may then be adjourned) to consider an application filed with the said Boazd of Adjustment requesting authority for variance from the provisions of the County zoning Resolution. All persons affected by the proposed vaziance aze invited to appeaz and state their views, protests, or objections. If you cannot appeaz personally at such meeting, then you aze urged to state your views by letter, particularly if you have objection to such variance, as the Boazd of Adjustment will give serious consideration to the opinions of surrounding property owners and others affected in deciding whether to grant or deny the request for variance. A VARIANCE GREATER THAN OR LESS THAN THAT REQUESTID COULD BE GRANTED. DATE AND TIME OF MEETING: Tuesday, April 4, 1995; 5:15 P'.M. _., __ Council Chambers, City Hall Goodwyne, John: requesting approval for a S' front yazd setback variance for the bedroom/gazage addition and a 23' front yard setback variance for the entry, where 30' is required fora 92,779 square foot lot in the AFR-10 zone district; a 27.5' her t vaziance where 30" is allowed fo 1, Lime Village ry ~ r a retaining structure within the setbacks; and a 5' height variance, where 20 is re aired for an accesso structure. "Property Location: 6770 Castle Creek Road; Lot 1, Block 1, Filing Neuman, Werner & Judy: requesting approval fora 10' rear yard setback vaziance, where 30' is required fora 31,122 square foot lot in the R-30 zone district, for construction of an addition to a single family residence. Property Location: 0171 Hunter Creek "Road; Lot 13, Block 4, Red Mountain Ranch. Frankel, Patricia: requesting approval fora 1.8' front yard setback vaziance, where 30' is required fora 15,015 squaze measu~ ed from the Hi hwa 82 rtctht-of-wa $ foand 68' arteri Lot 42, Block 1, Filing 1, Mountain Valley. coastructio'al highway setback variances, where 100' is required as g y g y' n of a new deck. Property Location: 42791 Highway 82; Aspen Chapel: requesting approval fora 10' west side yazd setback vaziance, where 20' is required in'the R-30 zone district; a 47' major'road setback vaziance, where 100' is required as measured from the Maroon Creek Road right-of- way; and a floor area variance to add an additional 903 squaze feet, where a maximum of 6,455.5 square feeE is allowed, and the structure is already 2,085.25 squaze feet over the allowed floor area; for construction of an addition to the church. Property Location:: 0077 Meadowood Drive; a part of Lots 15 and 16 in Section 11, Township 10 South, Range 85 West of the 6th 1?:M. Pitkin County: requesting approval for an arterial highway setback vaziance to locate an identification. sign adjacent to the highway, where 100' is required as measured from the Highway 82 right-of-way. The sign also requires the following vaziances; a 2' height vaziance, where 8' is allowed; a 91 squaze foot size vaziance, where a maximum of 8 squaze feet is allowed; and 6" and 12" variances for the height of the letters; where 18" and 12", respectively; aze allowed. Pitkin County Account- p.-=-=-_-_-_ -_-_- --=''_-_-_-= ----_. __ __ .,_, 1. Submitted to the Aspen Times on March 21, 1995. To Be Published in the As en Times on Mazch 25, 1995. .,, _ i - -~ ,~ Minutes Pitkin County Board of Adjustment June 6, 1995 Members Present: Rick Neiley Mchael'Cooper Ellie Brickham Rod Dyer 5hira Geller Members Absent• Staff: Bill Lukes Craig Feldman'' John Wheeler Paul Rudnick Joanna Schaffner, Zoning Enforcement Neiley opened the meeting at 5:15, PM and.. introduced the Board to those present. Case 95-04 John Goodwyne 6770 Castle Creek Road This case. was tabled previously. Gordon Denton was. present, representing the owner. Denton presented revised plans with the retaining wall reduced to a maximum height of 16 feet and length of 35 feet, and the proposed garage converted to a single car garage. The existing disturbed grade will be maintained.. The garage"'will be connected to the retaining wall. Additional landscaping will be provided on the retaini ge waf the driveway and the turn-around to_ screen the ' 11 from the road; the planter along the base of the wall has been eliminated. _Vines and aspens will be planted along ,.... <..M.. the wall, but the trees may not survive because of the footing of the wall. Schaffner noted that the wall is still considered an accessory . =a._ structure and is still within the setback The tra~'1 will continue Y ervice land. be and the lot line onto Forest~S,: ,. There was no public comment. Denton noted that the ,. previous design set the retaining wall farther back'nto the: hill to create more,aspace, but required that the wall be taller. Brickham stated that the applicant has complied with the suggestions made by the Board. Neiley stated that the revised plan is an improvement. He added that he would like to require the. applicant to submit a landscaping plan with the building permit application. Schaffner noted that the Board should require that the landscaping be in place within a certain amount of time, and that the applicant can be required to submit a bond to ensure that the landscaping is ~, Pitkin County Board of Adjustment y Minutes of June 6, 1995 completed. She also reminded the Board to consider screening in the winter. The Board discussed requiring a landscape plan. Dyer and Cooper were not in favor of requiring. a plan since the applicant has su sta ntially complied with the suggestions made by`the Board. forlco did not think a plan was necessary, but that a time frame mpleting the landscaping represented in the meeting should be included as a condition. Dyer moved to grant a 5 foot front yard setback variance for the bedroom/garage addition; a 23 foot front yard setback variance for the entry; a 19.5 foot front yard setback variance and a 2 foot west side yard setback variance for an addition to be added beneath the existin house• and a 13.5 foo oint to ern to~9.5 feet at th t heigYit variance at the highest P g 30 inches is allowed for a retaini south property boundary, where sub'ect to the landsca g g p ing 7 pin bein accomr lished w thin tonesgrowck, season'''of construction, based upon the plans stibmitted, due to existing conditions and topography. Cooper seconded.--the motion, and all were in favor. Case 95-09. Pitkin County Aspen/Pitkin County Airport This case was tabled to July 11. Case 95-13 Charles Urschel. Jr. Trust 18$9""M"arbcn Creek 'Road Nasser Sadeghi was present, representing the owner, to request a 12 foot front yard setback variance, where 30 feet is required for an app~'oximately 1 acre lot in the AFR-10 zone district; and a 7 , fromr thed Maroonk Creekg Ro gd brig' 100 feet is required as measured ht-of-way; for a second floor addition to a detached ara e. Sadeghi stated that the caretaker ,unit received approval from the Board of County Commissioners' in 1992. The applicants did not realize that'a variance was required to build the caretaker unit above the existin ara e which lies within the setback. He noted g g g that there is no other location available due to the narrowness of the property. Schaffner noted that the survey did not indicate the Maroon Creek Road right-of-way, so a specific amount has not been requested for the major road setback variance. There was no public comment. Neiley moved to approve a 12 foot front yard setback variance and a major road setback variance necessar`"y for construction of the ~. e:. ...v iW •..~.. rt. drsm e vAW~Ermmn"~ uL Mwnsvr YM.'IYS9 a.<¢: Vi' .q .. ...r . ~ ~~~ :..~, ,; .,~« , Minutes Pitkin County Board of Adjustment May 2, 1995 Members Present: Members Absent: Staff: Bill Lukes, Acting Chair John Wheeler Michael Cooper Craig Feldman Rick Neiley Shira Geller Paul Rudnick Rod Dyer Ellie Brickham Joanna Schaffner, Zoning Enforcement Lukes opened the meeting at 5:25 p.m. and introduced the Board to those present. ,:~ y _~ ,..,: _.. This case was tabled to June 6, 1995 at the site visit on April 1, 1995. Case 95-05, Werner & Judy Neuman 0171 Hunter Creek Road This case was tabled at the April 4, 1995 meeting. Tim Hagman was present, representing the owners, to request a 10' rear yard setback variance, where 30' is required for a 31, 122 square foot lot, for construction of an addition to a single family residence. Hagman stated that the owner has decided to pursue the proposed variance, rather than designing a second story addition which would not require a variance, but which would be more visually impactive. He added that he spoke with Frank Goldsmith, an adjacent property owner, who supports the variance with the restrictions agreed to by Neuman and Wish, Inc., another adjacent property owner. Lenny Oates, representing Wish, Inc., stated that Neuman has agreed P to lace conditions on thge variance to restrict the height of the addition to the same hei ht as th'e existing structure and not to construct a boundary fence. These restrictions would not apply if the property was redeveloped because a variance is granted for a specific structure. Wheeler noted that the height restriction would prevent the owner from constructin u er levels g pp on the residence, which is consistent with other approvals by the Board where a variance was granted for part of a site while development on another part of the site was restricted. Lukes agreed that the owner would give up the right to come back to the Board for future variances for this sytiw ~,., _. _ _. ~' Pitkin County Board of Adjustment 2 Minutes of April 4, 1995 pp p rt stated that the overall footprint of building will not be expanded because all but 50 square feet of the addition will be located in the empty space that is currently under the deck area. The new vestibule is the only portion that will not be under the decks. He added that the addition will not change the visual impact of cYiapel, and that the addition would have been visible from Highway 82 in any other location. There was no public comment. Brickham moved to grant a 10' west side yard setback variance, a 47' major road setback variance, and a floor area variance to allow a 903 square foot addition to the chapel, due to downzoning and the Chapel being a unique public structure needing to expand to accomodate public uses, subject to approval by the Board of County Commissioners of the Chapel's application for a GMQS Exemption and Scenic Overlay Review. Dyer seconded the motion, and all were in favor. Dyer and Lukes did not vote on this case. Gordon Denton was present, representing the owner, to request a 5' front yard setback variance for the bedroom/garage addition and a 23' front yard setback variance for the entry, where 30' is required for a 92,779 square foot lot in the AFR-10 zone district; a 27.5' height variance, where 30" is allowed, for a retaining structure within the setbacks; and a 5' height variance, where 20' is required for an accessory structure. Denton distributed a landscape plan for the area in front of the retaining wall. The landscaping'is designed to cover the wall. He stated that the retaining wall is below existing grade, and will prevent erosion. He noted that the entire wall will not be visible from Castle Creek Road. A garage with a master bedroom above is proposed on the uphill side of the house. Schaffner stated that the retaining structure can be considered an accessory structure that is located within the setback and exceeds the accessory height limit. Since the Code prohibits excavating more than 30" above or below natural grade within the setback, a 27.5' height variance is requested to allow the wall to be 30' in height within the setback. Outside the setback, the wall still exceeds the accessory height limit and requires a height variance of 5' to allow the wall to be 25' in height. The lot is within an approved subdivision, and does not have a building envelope. Neiley read into the record a letter from Rob Iwamoto of the U.S. ~~_ .. ...,. , ., _ ~ .,_.M. _ _ _. ~, .. ~ ~: w,a Pitkin County Board of Adjustment 3 Minutes of April 4, 1995 Forest Service, stating that the USFS has no comments for or against. the variance. request. Goodwyne has requested authorization for a driveway easement to cross National Forest land, and"Iwamoto noted that the easement would probably be granted. There was no public comment. Denton noted that the cut by the house was enlarged to allow for drilling of a well. Neiley stated that the retaining wall is massive and unnecessary, and the current access to the house seems adequate. The request does not enhance the access, and just creates a greater building area. He noted that he would like to view the site. Wheeler noted that the applicant has moved the topographical hardship in order to expand the site. Denton stated that the owners want to be able to turn around vehicles at the house. The owners requested to upgrade the existing road, but the USFS requested that it be moved up the hill because the existing road does not meet their road requirements, including exceeding a 12% grade at some points, and an easement for the existing road was not approved by the USFS. Wheeler questioned if there was any other developable area on the site. Denton replied that this is the flattest portion of the lot with the best access to the property. Wheeler moved to table to a site visit at 4:00 PM on Tuesday, April li. Brickham seconded the motion, and all were in favor. Case 95-05. Werner & Judv Neuman, 0171 Hunter Creek Road Cooper and Geller did not vote on this case. Werner Neuman and his architect., Tim Hagman, were present to request a 10' rear yard setback variance, where 30' is required for a 31,122 square foot lot, for construction of an addition to a single family residence. Neuman stated that the rear yard setback requirement increased from 20' to 30' when the new Code was adopted. The lot is triangular, therefore, the side and rear lot lines can be determined by the owner. If the north lot line was declared the side yard, the existing house is conforming; a second floor addition could be built that would not require a variance, but the addition would obstruct the, neighbors' views. If the north lot line was declared the rear yard, then the existing home is non-conforming; any addition would require a variance. The second alternative was UTE CITY LANDWORKS, INC. 2755 LOWER RIVER ROAD SNOWMASS, CO 81654 (303)923-5157 (303) 379-3399 Cellular MARCH 22,1995 GORDbN DENTON P:O. BOX 10666 ASPEN, CO 81612 (303) 925-2269 RE: GOODWYN RETAINING WALL LANDSCAPING. Legend for Print: c 8-10' Pinus flealis / LodgePole Pine. 8 to 10' at Planting. Estimated 17 years to attain,25' height. 2.5-3.5" Cal. Populus tremuloides /Aspen, l5 to 20' at Planting. n 4 Estimated 6-8 years to attain 25'+ height. ervice Berry. l8" at Plantiag. #5 Amelanchier aln-folia / 5 ., O Estimated it years to 12' height. ~ #1 Polygonum aubertii /Sliver Lace Vine. 12" Long at Planting. ,..... Estimated 16 years to reach, the top of the wall. Quantities of plant material are depicted on the landscape drawing. Should you have any further questions, Please call. Sincerely, Chris. ~! (~1 V'